The market continued its two-steps-forward, two-steps-backward behavior in October. Uncertainty regarding the midterm election likely contributed to such choppy trading; clarity on the election outcome is likely to remove a headwind for stocks in our opinion. While several well documented risks remain, we think the weight of the evidence is still supportive for the market.
The fundamental picture continues to be impressive. Economic growth has remained strong, with recent GDP data showing 3.4% annualized real growth. Notably, real final demand, which strips out volatile categories such as inventories and trade, showed growth of 4%, which is evidence that the growth is driven by genuine domestic demand rather than statistical quirks. Corporate America has continued to deliver as well, with S&P 500 earnings growth of 30.2% this quarter through 10/30, according to data from Factset. Importantly, this earnings growth is not just confined to mega-cap tech companies, as the earnings growth of the other 493 stocks in the index has outpaced that of the so-called Mag7 this quarter. Additionally, inflation data shows that price increases are concentrated in a few areas of the economy, particularly energy, rather than being broad-based.
We have written about the rotations that have taken place in the market over the past several months. Leadership has repeatedly shifted between technology and other sectors, with periods of strong technology performance followed by sharp selloffs accompanied by strength elsewhere. This behavior has been dramatic – with data from Evercore recently showing that almost 40% of the stocks within the S&P 500 have been negatively correlated to the index itself – and has caused some investor angst. However, periodic rotation is a feature of healthy markets. It is an encouraging sign that investors have sought stability in formerly-lagging sectors rather than abandoning the market entirely.
Over the past month, technology has again been at the center of the recent weakness, particularly companies associated with the AI investment cycle. Election results have added another layer of uncertainty to the group, but we think it is important to separate the political narrative from the underlying fundamentals. First, earnings across much of the technology sector have remained strong, with sector-wide earnings growth of 67.2% compared to expectations for 63% at the beginning of the quarter, according to Factset. The extraordinary investment taking place in AI infrastructure continues, and the companies enabling that buildout are generally producing results that support the longer-term investment case. Secondly, technology stocks have performed well under a wide variety of political regimes. Presidents and Congresses can influence individual industries at the margin, but over time earnings, innovation and competitive advantages have mattered considerably more to shareholder returns than which party controls Washington. Valuation also provides useful context for the recent decline. Given the recent pullback and continue earnings growth, technology valuations are now roughly equal to those seen at the bottom of bear market in October 2022. That does not mean technology stocks cannot fall further, but it does mean that a significant amount of the valuation excess that concerned investors earlier in the cycle has already been removed. Selling technology stocks with these earnings growth rates at these valuations appears short sighted to us.
History also provides a warning against placing too much confidence in the market narratives that emerge immediately after an election. Investors naturally try to identify the likely “winners” and “losers” from a new political landscape, but, as we discussed on our most recent investment strategy call, those initial conclusions frequently prove incorrect. Markets are complex systems, and earnings, interest rates, economic growth, valuations and company-specific execution ultimately tend to overwhelm simple political narratives.
Midterm elections have historically marked the end of a period of elevated political uncertainty and the beginning of a seasonally strong period for stocks. In every midterm cycle since 1942, the market has been higher by the following June 30th, with an average gain of approximately 15% according to data from Bespoke. History is never a guarantee, and every cycle brings its own risks, but the consistency of that pattern is a useful reminder that periods of political uncertainty have often created better opportunities than investors expected at the time.
There are still risks to monitor. While the earnings picture is exceptional today; it is likely to moderate in 2027. The extent of that moderation will be important in determining future market returns. And while our fundamental work still supports an unambiguously positive view for technology stocks, our process demands that we incorporate the message of the market as well. The market can overreact in the short term, but trying to “outsmart” the market is rarely a winning strategy over the long term. We will continue to follow our process, weigh the fundamental & technical evidence together, and position accounts accordingly.
This is being provided solely for informational and illustrative purposes, is not an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any securities. The factual information given herein is taken from sources that we believe to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to accuracy or completeness. Opinions expressed are subject to change without notice and do not take into account the particular investment objectives, financial situation or needs of individual investors. Employees of Janney Montgomery Scott LLC or its affiliates may, at times, release written or oral commentary, technical analysis or trading strategies that differ from the opinions expressed here.